In 1691 there was an amnesty for Highland rebels (Jacobites) provided
they swore allegiance to the new king, William, by the end of the year.
The Chiefs sought clearance from their former king to do so; it came in
late December so (owing to the weather and distances) few met the
deadline. It was decided to make an example of someone - and the Glencoe
MacDonalds were selected, since they were not too numerous and had a
long record of raiding other areas in Highlands and Lowlands alike.
In February, two companies of the Argyll Regiment were ordered by
regional headquarters at Fort William, to proceed from their barracks at
Ballachulish and be billeted in Glencoe (pictured). All was as per a
normal army billeting till orders arrived on the 12th; Robert Campbell's
command were to exterminate the Glencoe MacDonalds. At dawn they
commenced; about 40 were killed directly and the 400 or so others
escaped to freeze in the mountains.
Though Campbell of Glenlyon commanded the troops, his very specific
orders came from the King himself - but Campbell became something of a
scapegoat in later years. The sense of outrage in the Highlands was not
because the MacDonalds had been hammered, they were not in any case
particularly popular with their neighbours; it was because they acted
correctly in following the Highland conventions of hospitality, but had
then been attacked by their guests. Others of the Scottish nobility,
particularly Lord Stair, had planned and pressed for ordering of the
massacre, and effectively forced Campbell into carrying it out. The
Argyll regiment subsequently fought in the Low Countries of Europe with
great distinction, till its disbandment in 1697.
Argyll soldiers forewarned some of the MacDonalds at Glencoe, so they
could escape. The Campbells themselves do not really deserve their
negative historical image. After the battle of Culloden in 1746 when
the defeated Jacobite soldiers were being systematically hunted down and
killed by Cumberland's army, most of the Campbell militia seem to have
tried to minimise the number caught, and showed little inclination to
persecute their fellow Scots - in contrast to the zeal of Cumberland's
Lowland battalions. By that time the king was a Hanoverian, George I,
father of the ruthless but militarily competent Duke of Cumberland.
Officers of the regiments actually from Hanover and attached to
Cumberland's command are on record as protesting at his brutality
towards the Highlanders. The real villains were Scottish Lowlanders and
some English, not all.
ALLAN BRECK STEWART
At the beginning of the 1745 uprising, a soldier in General Cope's army
surprised and smashed at Prestonpans by Highland Jacobite forces, was
Allan Breck Stewart, formerly an officer in Ogilvie's Regiment in the
service of France. Taken prisoner by the rebels, he changed sides -
fighting in the Appin Regiment till Culloden, then accompanying his
Commander, Colonel Stuart of Ardsheil, into exile in France. Breck was
now wanted both as a rebel and as an army deserter. He is thought to
have become a Jacobite agent and (possibly) hit-man - the unsolved
assassination of Campbell of Glenure may have been one of his
operations. Colin Campbell (the 'Red Fox') was an officer in
Cumberland's Highland Militia, noted for his willingness to denounce
former rebels, and was King's Factor for Lochaber and Appin. He was
shot. Breck, with assistance, escaped from Scotland and in 1753 resumed
his commission in France's service. In America during the Seven
Years War (1756-63), he found that amongst some Hanoverian troops
surrounded by the French and facing extinction, was a detachment of
Highland soldiers, from Argyll. Breck infiltrated the British camp, and
arranged with the Scots that he would leave a gap in his own force, such
that they alone would escape. Robert Louis Stevenson closely based a
character of the same name in his novel Kidnapped on Allan Breck
Stewart.
|