|
| 1. |
State of the World |
| by Lester Brown, et al. (Earthscan, annual). |
|
This is a comprehensive and authoritative survey of many
of the world's key trends, published each year. The press
releases regularly put out by the Worldwatch Institute also
provide a quick way of keeping on top of the mountain of data
about the Earth's festering ills. Look them up on the Internet
(www.worldwatch.org).
The Institute also publishes a series of A5 booklets on specific
issues in a series called the Worldwatch Papers, which by
mid-2000 numbered more than a 150 volumes, with topics ranging
from the disastrous depletion of underground water aquifers to
the pestilential dangers of new (and old) diseases.
| 2. |
It's a Matter of Survival |
| by Anita Gordon & David Suzuki (Harper Collins, 1991). |
|
It is difficult to pick out one book that captures the breadth
and depth of today's environmental, economic and social crises,
not least the way they interact. This one does convey the
urgency of the situation and the dangers we face, even if global
overwarming were to turn out to be an illusion cooked up by a
few overheated imaginations. The book draws upon a more
conventional humanist perspective rather than a deeper
ecological sensibility. It is also a bit dated by now. That
said, it remains a firm rebuttal of the phoney 'good news'
environmentalism being peddled by the likes of Gregg Easterbrook
and organisations such as the British grouping Forum for the
Future, let alone latter day Panglosses like Julian Simons and
Wilfred Beckerman. It boldly underlines that most fundamental
truth that, whatever the good cause, it will be a lost one
unless we put the Earth first in both values, public policy and
private lifestyles.
See also Beyond the Limits by Donella Meadows et al (Earthscan,
1992), an update of the classic Limits to Growth, the study
originally commissioned by the Club of Rome. The Cassandra
Conference edited by Paul Ehrlich and John Holdren (Texas A&M
Univ. Pr., 1987), brings together great analysts such as George
Woodwell and Earl Cook, all of whom are prepared to ask that
great green question: 'how much is enough'? Statistics do date
quickly, though it is possible to check for recent data from
many good on-line sources not least the websites maintained by
the Worldwatch Institute (see above) and that run by the David
Suzuki Foundation, which also lists some follow-up studies to
the above book. Of course, it is hard to be precise about broad
trends, not least their speed of development. It is easy to
dismiss such warnings as 'crying wolf' when predicted disasters
do not happen in the immediate future. Yet, in broad historical
terms, a few decades one way or the other is of minuscule
significance. Even more important is the stark reality that the
damage being done by human activities to the Earth's
life-support systems is cumulative and can cross the point of no
return without anything dramatic highlighting the fact.
Although arguments about 'resources running out' miss the big
picture about our sickening planet, it is important to consult
the writings of the Australian writer Ted Trainer, some of the
best pieces being in the form of magazine articles. He
rigorously exposes the widespread complacency about long-term
fossil fuel and mineral availability as well as unwarranted
optimism about the potential of solar and other 'alternative'
resource supplies. A number of studies focus more on the
political and economic aspects on the global crisis. In
particular they debunk the widespread claims that a 'long boom'
lies ahead and that the combination of parliamentary democracy
and free market economics has successfully brought history to a
happy ending. Despite, in some cases, a lack of deep ecological
understanding, there is much good material in books such as The
Age of Insecurity by Larry Elliott and Dan Atkinson (Verso,
1998), The Case Against the Global Economy edited by Jerry
Mander and Edward Goldsmith (Sierra Club Books, 1996), Economic
Horror by Viviane Forrester (Blackwell, 1999), False Dawn: The
Delusions of Global Capitalism by John Gray (Granta Books,
1999), and, with focus on a particular example of the whole
monster of so-called development, the Narada Valley project in
India, The Cost of Living by Arundhati Roy (Flamingo, 1999).
Light should be shed on those who benefit the most from the
evils chronicled in such works and who actively block remedial
action. Good sources include Green Backlash: Global Subversion
of the Environmental Movement by Andrew Rowell (Routledge,
1996), Global Spin: The Corporate Assault on Environmentalism by
Sharon Beder (Green books, 1997) and, with more humour though
less environmental awareness, Downsize This! by Michael Moore,
creator of the TV series TV Nation, (Boxtree, 1996). Good cases
studies from the UK of the process of corporate take-over and
the subservience of mainstream political parties can be found in
The Captive State by George Monbiot ( Macmillan, 2000) and The
Captive Party by Michael Barratt Brown (Spokesman Books, 2001 -
a critique of Britain's 'New Labour' Party).
| 3. |
A Green History of the World |
| by Clive Ponting (Penguin, 1991). |
|
This is a popular presentation of the ecological view of
history, taking the people-environment interaction as the
crucial characteristic of any society and the most decisive
determinant of its future. In passing, it provides a healthy
corrective to 'radical nostalgia' which paints a romantic
picture of indigenous societies and 'vernacular cultures'.
Sadly, environmental destruction and social oppression have long
dogged human footsteps.
For an analysis of the last hundred years in particular, see
Something New Under the Sun: An Environmental History of the
Twentieth Century by John McNeil (Allen Lane, 2000). Karl
Polanyi's The Great Transformation (Octagon, 1980, originally
1944) provides a lucid analysis of the rise of modern industrial
society and the emergence of 'economic man'. Amongst the
intellectual histories, Peter Marshall's Nature's Web: an
Exploration of Ecological Thought (Simon and Shuster, 1992)
stands out, though the writings of Carolyn Merchant, Clarence
Glacken, Roderick Nash, Max Oelschlaeger are all very useful as
well.
Follow up by reading works by the growing number of academics
who are building an ecological theory of history and historical
change. See, for examples, books by writers such as Alfred
Crosby, Jared Diamond, Stanley Diamond, Donald Hughes, Marshall
Sahlins, Donald Worster, and in a perhaps more popular mode,
Farley Mowat. One book stands out, however. It is Rogue Primate:
an Exploration of Human Domestication by John Livingston (Key
Porter Books, 1994), partly a history of human evolution - how
it has contributed to the present crisis - and partly the
presentation of a non-human-centred philosophy. Amongst other
things, it exposes the crude reductionism that blames
contemporary woes solely upon capitalism or indeed any cause of
a purely economic nature. The works of Paul Shepherd also shed a
great deal of light on such matters.
Whilst on the subject of history, there is another area well
worth further study. In the past, a small number of very
prescient writers saw the destructive road society has long been
travelling. They also proposed more ecologically sustainable and
less exploitative ways forward. Their writings refute the
frequently proffered excuse that past destruction was merely
accidental, an excusable misunderstanding, since people didn't
know then what they know now. These visionaries did recognise
the follies of their times and courageously said so, often being
pilloried for their efforts. Their ranks include Henry Thoreau,
George Marsh, John Muir, Fairfield Osborn, William Vogt, Paul
Sears, Baker Brownell, Aldo Leopold, Frank Fraser Darling and,
last but not least, the great Rachel Carson, who was subject to
a particularly vicious witch hunt. All their writings repay
close study.
| 4. |
Betrayal of Science and Reason |
| by Paul & Anne Ehrlich (Island Press, 1998). |
|
A first-class response to the 'brown backlash'. The latter
argues that fears about global warming and other environmental
problems are just empty hot air. However, the book also provides
a solid guide to the scientific side to green thinking, not
least on issues like overpopulation and biodiversity.
For a superb example of an academic textbook on environmental
sciences, which also has a lot of good material about
sustainable alternatives to despoliation-as-usual, look no
further than Living in the Environment by G. Tyler Miller
(Wadsworth, with new editions appearing on a regular basis). It
contains an excellent bibliography as well. Ecology and Our
Endangered Life-Support Systems by Eugene Odum (Sinauer, 1989)
is also a good guide to the scientific side of green politics.
Odum is a veteran ecologist who is not afraid to speak out and
roundly condemn the havoc being wrought across the planet. Too
many scientists seem content to interpret the world (or, rather,
smaller and smaller fragments of it) rather than change it for
the better. See also The Diversity of Life by Edward O. Wilson
(Penguin, 1992) and A Primer for Environmental Literacy by Frank
Golley (Yale, 1998). The need for 'connected thinking', see
things as a whole, is underlined in The Web of Life: A New
Synthesis of Mind and Matter by Fritjof Capra (Flamingo, 1997).
| 5. |
Elephant in the Volkswagen: Facing the Tough Questions About Our Crowded Country |
| by Lindsey Grant et al (Freeman, 1992). |
|
Too many people ignorantly believe that human numbers do not
count. This collection of essays, focusing not on countries with
exploding populations such as India but on the USA, demonstrates
that human population growth is the biggest single source of the
Earth's woe's and one which multiplies the effects of other
malign pressures, not least those from overconsumption and
inappropriate technology. In passing, it outlines the ecological
approach to specific issues such as immigration and the rising
percentage of elderly people.
Follow-up reading should include Paul and Anne Ehrlich's
magisterial analysis The Population Explosion (Hutchinson, 1990)
as well as the many magazine articles the two, sometimes in
partnership with John Holdren, have written on the issue. See
also World War 111: Population and the Biosphere at the End of
the Millennium by Michael Tobias (Continuum, 1998). Mention must
be made of the writings of Jack Parsons who has struggled
tirelessly to warn of the threat from overpopulation. Some are
hard to find but it is worth searching out books such as
Population Versus Liberty (Pemberton Books(1971), and Human
Population Competition: A Study of the Pursuit of Power through
Numbers (Edwin Mellen Press,1998).
The personal dimensions to this issue and their links to the
'big picture' are well explored in Bill McKibben's Maybe One: A
Personal and Environmental Argument for Single-Child Families
(Simon & Shuster, 1998) Excellent material is published
regularly in the journal Population and Environment, until
recently edited by Virginia Abernethy, herself the author of
numerous good books on population growth. Other good sources of
evidence and argument about the realities of overpopulation
include the Bulletin of the Carrying Capacity Network
(Washington, USA) and The Pherologist (from a coalition of
European campaign groups, published in Emmeloord, Netherlands).
| 6. |
Questioning Technology |
| edited by John Zerzan & Alice Carnes (Freedom Press, 1988). |
|
There are two particularly bad ideas about technology. One is
the almost religious faith that technology is the answer,
believers thinking that social and environmental problems can be
made to disappear simply by waving the magic wand of applied
science. The second is the belief that technology is simply a
neutral tool, its impacts dependent upon the identity and
purposes of its controllers. This anthology is a great
introduction to a more critical view, one which pulls no punches
when it comes to such false dawns as biotechnology and
computerisation Sadly, that great technological pie-in-the-sky,
the so-called 'green car', is overlooked.
Follow up by reading authors such as Jacques Ellul (The
Technological Bluff, Erdman, 1990), Neil Postman (try his
Technopoly, Vintage Books, 1993) and Jerry Mander (especially
the first two parts on 'megatechnology' in his In the Absence of
the Sacred, Sierra Club Books, 1992). It is well worth searching
out Eugene Schwartz's Overskill: The Decline of Technology in
Modern Civilisation (Ballantine, 1971) a much needed antidote to
today's high-tech euphoria. It also includes a careful
dissection of the limits of logical empiricism. From an older
generation, the writings of Lewis Mumford stand out. All these
works demonstrate that 'alternative' isn't necessarily
appropriate and that, if a technology is 'lean' and 'clean', it
still might be far from green.
| 7. |
Amusing Ourselves to Death |
| by Neil Postman (Methuen, 1986). |
|
Human culture is suffering from a process of degradation,
'dumbing down', that parallels the ruination of environmental
systems. Indeed the former is a growing hindrance to any
sensitivity towards and understanding of the latter. Postman is
a sure-footed guide, focusing in this work on the impact of
modern mass media.
For a more general overview see Dumbing Down: Essays on the
Strip-Mining of American Culture, edited by K. Washburn & J.
Thornton. (Norton, 1997), a collection which concentrates on
America but, since 'Americanisation' is a major facet of the
process globally, it remains relevant to readers everywhere.
Other notable contributors on the issue include Robert Hughes
(The Culture of Complaint, Harvill, 1994), Richard Sennett (The
Corrosion of Character, Norton, 1995), Serge Latouche
(Westernization of the World, Polity Press, 1996), George Ritzer
(The McDonaldization of Society, Pine Forge press, 1996) Carl
Hiaissan (Team Rodent: How Disney Devours the World, Ballantine,
1998), John Miller (Egotopia: Narcissism and the New American
Landscape, Univ. Alabama Pr., 1997). For more focus on the
commercialisation of culture, a good starting point is Naomi
Klein (No Logo: Taking Aim of the Brand Bullies, Flamingo,
2000). See also writers around the magazines Adbuster
(Vancouver) and, from Chicago, The Baffler (there is a good
collection of articles from the latter in Commodify Your
Dissent: The Business of Culture in the New Gilded Age, edited
by T. Frank and M. Weiland, Norton, 1997).
| 8. |
Deep Ecology for the 21st Century: Readings on the Philosophy & Practice of the New Environmentalism |
| edited by George Sessions ( Shambhala, 1995). |
|
This is a weighty collection of essays from a variety of
writers, with especially valuable introductions to each section
by the American philosopher George Sessions. These writings
demonstrate that there is a deep crisis in human character and
culture, which a crude politics of anti-capitalism or indeed any
programme based on economics fails to address and therefore can
provide no lasting answers. However, the volume is
correspondingly weaker on practical problems, not least the role
of market economics and vested interests, and too focused on
personal transformation.
It is still worthwhile dipping into Deep Ecology: Living As If
Mattered by Bill Devall and George Sessions (Gibbs M Smith,
1985). Particularly important is its critique of 'resource
managerialism', now often masquerading as environmentalism but,
in actuality, but a front for a more sophisticated domination
and manipulation of the Earth (as typified by the Brundtland
Report, for example). The same applies to that new scam,
'sustainable development'. Other chapters outline other sources
of ecological thought, not least from the worldviews of 'primal
peoples' and non-western philosophies, something this brief
guide has had to ignore.
See also Ecology, Community and Lifestyle: Outline Of An
Ecosophy by Norwegian Arne Naess, translated and edited by David
Rothenberg, (Cambridge University Press, 1991). Naess drew the
vital distinction between what he called 'shallow
environmentalism' and 'deep ecology', a much more consistent and
meaningful sense of solidarity with the Earth. The Arrogance of
Humanism by David Ehrenfeld (OUP, 1981) remains an essential
read, not least for its dissection of the ideology of progress
and its offspring 'development'. He is also good at showing how
conservation programmes based on a utilitarian ethic are doomed
to failure.
The best demolition job on the limits of reductionist and
mechanistic thinking can be found in the first part of Where the
Wasteland Ends by Theodore Roszak (Doubleday, 1973). For a more
specific critique of the individualistic and materialistic
values that underpin mainstream economic thinking as well as a
critique of economic growth policies, try The Death of
Industrial Civilisation by Joel Jay Kassiola (SUNY Press, 1990).
Modern thinking has also been polluted by much postmodernist
rubbish. Its pretensions and foolishness are well and truly
buried by Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont in their best seller
Intellectual Impostures (Profile Books, 1997). Sadly, some of
their strictures can be applied to much material being produced
by the green movement. Another powerful critique of the dominant
worldview is The Way: An Ecological World-View by Edward
Goldsmith (Green Books, 1996). Drawing upon anthropological
evidence from past cultures, he also shows that there is another
way of looking at the world, one which will cherish not destroy
it. Don't be put off by the rather schematic form of
presentation. A very valuable collection of past essays by
Goldsmith can be found in The Great U-Turn: Deindustrialising
Society (Green Books, 1988). Much wisdom can be found in the
pages of Home Place by Stan Rowe (NeWest, 1990), who casts a
particularly sharp eye over a wide range of scientific,
aesthetic and policy issues. A very valuable attempt to bridge
'philosophy' and the formulation of a coherent political
platform is Regarding Nature: Industrialism and Deep Ecology by
Andrew McLaughlin (State University of New York Press, 1993).
| 9. |
A Sand County Almanac: With Essays on Conservation from Round River |
| by Aldo Leopold (Oxford University Press, 1987 edition). |
|
Few writers match Leopold's sensitivity to the meaning and
importance of wilderness as well as his awareness of the need to
go beyond a human-centred perspective of "resource management"
(which has cloaked, indeed legitimised much environmental
destruction). He was no armchair sentimentalist, having had
extensive experience in forestry and game management. His basic
ideas and metaphors, e.g. "thinking like a mountain", and "the
Land Ethic", provide solid building blocks for a new worldview
at one with the rest of Nature. He also had a way with words
that captures the beauty and wonders of our world, though such
sensibility can leave one even more in pain at its destruction.
Another collection of his writings can be found in For the
Health of the Land (Island Press, 1999). See also The Essential
Aldo Leopold, edited by C. Meine and R. Knight (Univ. Wisconsin
Press, 2000)
| 10. |
Naked Emperors: Essays of a Taboo-Stalker |
| by Garrett Hardin (Kaufmann, 1982). |
|
Greens need both kind hearts and hard heads. The controversial
American biologist Garrett Hardin cuts through a lot of the soft
sentiment and piety about relationships between individuals and
groups and between people and planet. His paper on the so-called
'tragedy of the commons' remains one of the most cited articles
of all time. Few theses contain the potential to upset so many
different brands of politics. The disastrous dynamic spotlighted
by Hardin undermines the case for, on the one hand,
laissez-faire 'market' economics, based on the individual
consumer, and, on the other, anarchist and libertarian politics,
based on individuals 'doing their own thing'. The 'tragedy'
model can be used to show how the former, economic
libertarianism, and the latter, social libertarianism, are but
different sides of the same bad coin. No wonder the theory has
so many enemies. Hardin's critique of the 'cornucopian' vision
of ever-expanding entitlements is particularly forceful. Some of
his historical comparisons can be questioned (some traditional
commons were actually quite well managed) while his concept of
'lifeboat ethics' in relation to the problems of countries
suffering from poverty and environmental decline is also flawed.
Nevertheless, Hardin has been a crucial thinker on both
environmental and social problems. See also his other
collections, notably Living Within Limits: Ecology, Economics
and Population Taboos (Oxford, 1993)
|