|
| 11. |
Blueprint for Survival |
| by Edward Goldsmith et al. (Penguin, 1972). |
|
A true oldie but goldie. It still contains the best diagnosis of
our mounting social and environmental ills and the best policy
framework for curing them. It shows that a coherent green
programme cannot be constructed on the basis of 'grievance
politics', mixing together the demands from disaffected groups
on the edges of society as some radicals have tried to do. Such
recipes can only produce dogs' dinners. The Blueprint should be
the starting point for all those seeking to flesh out the
details of a manifesto for sustainability. Its main weakness was
a naive faith in the willingness, indeed ability, of governments
drawn from mainstream politics to listen to reason. They didn't
and they won't. Its other main failing ironically was too much
moderation. Things are slip sliding away faster than even this
forthright statement anticipated.
| 12. |
Ecology and the Politics of Scarcity |
| by William Ophuls (Freeman, 1992). |
|
This contains the best single presentation of the green critique
of expansionism. Ophuls also provides a superb explanation of
the dynamic of the 'tragedy of the commons'. In particular, it
demonstrates how harmful consequences can flow from the
cumulative effect of harmless and otherwise well-intentioned
decisions. It knocks on the head the soft-headed sentiment that
believes that, as one 'green' book put it, "if you care for
people, you care for the planet". Sadly, life is a bit more
complex. Ophuls should be read by all those who simply blame
everything on 'them', be they crooked capitalists or bossy
bureaucrats. He also shows how important it is to learn from
conservative thinkers such as Edmund Burke, mindless written off
as hopeless reactionaries by simple-minded radicals. Follow up
with his Requiem for Modern Politics (Westview, 1997).
See also Biosphere Politics by Jeremy Rifkin (Harper, 1992), a
wide-ranging work, with much insight into the downside of the
worldview that emerged out of the Enlightenment as well as into
specific issues such as genetic engineering. The writings of
Christopher Lasch also shed much light both on modern society as
a whole (e.g. his Culture of Narcissism, Abacus, 1980) and
political movements, especially his Revolt of the Elite and the
Betrayal of Democracy (Norton, 1995) and The True and Only
Heaven: Progress and Its Critics (Norton, 1991).
| 13. |
Let the Mountains Talk, Let the Rivers Run |
| by David Brower (Harper, 1996). |
|
There are a number of personal statements by leading activists
but few have been so active as Brower or write with such
eloquence and force. A really lively and stimulating book, one
that really does recharge the batteries of tired campaigners.
Mention must be made of Edward Abbey, Wendell Berry and Gary
Snyder all of whose writings exude wisdom combined with an
enthralling way with words. Abbey wrote widely but the best
starting point is Desert Solitaire (Peregrine Smith, 1981),
partly based on his experiences as a National Park ranger. He
also wrote some great novels, which manage to combine anger and
humour, plus some good storylines. The best place to begin when
exploring the many writings of Wendell Berry might be The
Unsettling of America (Sierra Books, 1982), a demonstration of
how to link a critique of a specific aspect of modern society
(industrialised agriculture) with broader insights into the
values and goals on which it is founded. A number of books have
gathered together the many wonderful essays penned by Berry,
eg. The Gift of Good Land (North Point Press, 1981), Standing
By Words (North Point Press, 1983), Home Economics (North Point
Press, 1987), What are People For? (North Point Press, 1990),
Sex, Economy, Freedom and Community (North Point Press, 1993)
and especially Life is a Miracle: An Essay Against Modern
Superstition (Counterpoint, 2000), a critique of the new
'determinist' science, a cult that now attracts many
worshippers.
Gary Snyder: Dimensions of a Life edited by Jon Halper (Sierra
Club Books, 1991) celebrates one of America's greatest
contemporary thinkers and poets. Snyder's sensitivity to
undomesticated nature gives his work an edge perhaps lacking in
Wendell Berry's works. He too has authored many great books,
many of them collections of essays, talks and interviews. The
major ones are Earth Household (New Directions, 1969), The Old
Ways (City Light Books, 1977), Turtle Island (New Directions,
1974), The Real Work (New Directions, 1980), Axe Handles (North
Point Press, 1983), The Practice of the Wild (North Point Press,
1990) Coming into the Watershed (Pantheon, 1994) and A Place in
Space: Ethics, Aesthetics and Watersheds (Counterpoint, 1995).
| 14. |
Eco-socialism or Eco-capitalism? a critical analysis of
humanity's fundamental choices |
| by Saral Sarkar (Zed Books, 1999). |
|
Saral Sarkar was born in India in 1936 but since the early 80s
has lived in Germany. This background helps him provide extra
insights into the global nature of the modern crisis as well as
avoid rose-tinted images of the so-called 'developing' world.
The peoples of those lands are not helpless victims, as
portrayed in much radical literature, but often active and
willing participants in the process of 'maldevelopment'. Sarkar
cuts through the nonsense of those who think western-style
affluence could - or even should - be generalised around the
world. He demonstrates that capitalism can never be made green,
contrary to the 'market-based' solutions ('natural capitalism'
etc.) being touted by people like Paul Hawken and Amory Lovins.
However Sarkar has no illusions about the experiences of the
various 'non-capitalist' (or, perhaps more aptly, 'state
capitalist') regimes that emerged from the Bolshevik Revolution
of 1917. He makes a convincing case for a new kind of socialism,
based on solidarity both between people and between people and
planet. His vision goes not go beyond a somewhat restrictive
utilitarian view of nature. Yet his arguments are vital to the
development of a practical programme for an ecological economy.
| 15. |
Steady-State Economics |
| by Herman Daly (Freeman, 1977). |
|
The signals sent by conventional economics have been signposts
to long-term ruin. For people have done more than Daly to mark
out another road, both in theoretical and policy terms. The
concept of the steady-state is much misunderstand yet it
represents the essence of the green economic alternative. Daly
explains why it is so vital and puts forward challenging ideas
about how to institutionalise it. His focus on the throughput of
energy and raw materials in the human economy dispels a lot of
the fog generated by vague words like 'growth' and
'development'. There is, of course, much noise about 'new
economics' but most of it fails to go beyond a very pale green
Keynesianism. Daly also anticipated reformist policies such as
pollution levies and emissions trading, showing that they are
the wrong tool applied to the wrong end of the economic process.
See also the works of Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen (especially his
magnum opus The Entropy Law and the Economic Process, Harvard
UP, 1971) and the various writings of E. J. Mishan. Arguments
against 'growthmania' are also developed in The Growth Illusion
by Richard Douthwaite (Green Books, 1992). For a compendium of
examples of how 'giantism' (bigger-is-more-beautiful) becomes
increasingly counter-productive and unsustainable in all its
forms, social, economic and technological, look up Human Scale
by Kirkpatrick Sale (Secker and Warburg, 1980). The name of
Fritz Schumacher is often linked to the phrase "small is
beautiful" but all his writings provide a rich treasure chest of
wisdom. Leopold Kohr might be less well known but he too had
many insights into the curse of bigness and the need to break up
today's megastates.
| 16. |
The Conserver Society: Alternatives for Sustainability |
| by Ted Trainer (Zed, 1995). |
|
This is the best nuts-and-bolts vision of a sustainable society.
It is firmly grounded in the theory of limits-to-growth and the
fact that we must all learn to tread more lightly and to share
smaller pies as the American writer Tom Bender once put it.
Trainer shows that a no-longer-affluent society (in conventional
terms) could not only be much safer but also much richer in all
kinds of other ways.
The skills of 'living lightly' will partly depend upon an
awareness of how heavily we now stamp down on the planet. In
this field pioneering work has been done by William Rees and
Mathis Wackernagel. See in particular their study of the human
'boot', Our Ecological Footprint (New Society Publishers, 1996).
A good companion is Sharing The World by Michael Carley and
Philippe Spapens (Earthscan, 1998). Case studies of people trying
to build such alternatives can be found in a series of short
books produced by New Society Publishers, particularly Turtle
Talk: Voices for A Sustainable Future (edited by Christopher and
Judith Plant, 1990), Putting Power in its Place: Create
Community Control (edited by Christopher and Judith Plant,
1992), and Futures By Design: The Practice of Ecological
Planning (edited by Doug Aberley, 1994). Richard Douthwaite's
Short Circuit: Strengthening Local Economies for Security in an
Unstable World (Green Books, 1996) and Sustainable Communities:
The Potential for EcoNeighbourhoods, edited by Hugh Barton
(Earthscan, 1999) provide many encouraging case studies and
valuable proposals. A book that manages to make the link between
core green values and questions of individual lifestyle and
public policy is Simple in Means, Rich in Ends: Practising Deep
Ecology (Green Print, 1990).
Another critical area is the reorganisation of government
structures. The construction of a conserver society will depend
upon devolution of powers to the lowest appropriate level (often
the framework created by watershed and river basins, sometimes
smaller, sometimes larger, and, given the predicaments facing
the planet as a whole, continental and even global in a few
cases). Those latter cases will be options only of the last
resort given the negative side-effects when decisions are made
by those who will not be affected by them and who therefore
receive no feedback on the error of their choices. National
and local government boundaries ignore the geological,
hydrological or biological patterns on which constitution,
economy and culture all depend. The most obvious examples are
the straight lines plotted across maps to divide one political
zone from another, regardless of biophysical and cultural
contours. Many campaigners for decentralisation fall into the
same trap, failing to connect their proposals to those
underlying world of biogeography Similarly debates about
'national culture' ignore the primary need to rebuild human
cultures so that they become attuned to and reflect the
specificities of local places - its climate, its landforms, its
soils, plants, waters and wildlife.
A very useful collection of material on what is often called
'bioregionalism' is Home! A Bioregional Reader, edited by Van
Andruss et al. (New Society Publishers, 1990). See also
Boundaries of Home: Mapping for Local Empowerment edited by Doug
Aberley (New Society Publishers, 1993) and Reinhabiting a
Separate Country edited by Peter Berg (Planet Drum, 1975). The
various writings of Raymond Dasmann played a pioneering in such
thinking.
The search for a sustainable society will be aided by much more
humility about contemporary technological prowess as well as
more respect for the achievements of many traditional cultures.
A good aid here is Helena Norberg-Hodge's Ancient Futures:
Learning from Ladakh (Sierra Club Books, 1991).
| 17. |
Ecological Literacy |
| by David Orr (SUNY Press, 1992). |
|
Any hopes of sustaining a 'conserver society' will depend most
of all upon the education of its future citizens. Contrary to
the position of many radical critics of contemporary education
systems, there will be much prescription in the curriculum we
need. Its content is the key issue, with matters such as
organisational form, funding and assessment methods significant
but nonetheless secondary questions. There is no better guide
than David Orr, whose study also has much light to shed on the
meaning of 'sustainability'. See also his Earth in Mind: On
Education, Environment and the Human Prospect (Island Press,
1994).
Critical Essays on Education and the Recovery of the Ecological
Imperative by C. A Bowers (Teachers College, 1993) provides a
first-rate critique of the ecological failure of modern
educational theory and practice. It also dissects the fallacy of
thinking that a computer on every school desk will improve
matters. Another work by Bowers, Let Them Eat Data: How
Computers Affect Education, Cultural Diversity and the Prospects
of an Ecologically Sustainable Future (Univ. Georgia Press, 2000),
broadens and deepens that latter argument.
| 18. |
Green Architecture: Design for a Sustainable Future |
| by Brenda and Robert Vale (Thames and Hudson, 1991). |
&nsp;
|
More and more people live in urban environments but the modern
megalopolis is as ugly and oppressive as it is unsustainably
rapacious in the demands it places on both local and distant
ecosystems. However, there is an alternative and this book
provides examples as well as draws out the principles on which
planning must be based.
A number of leading thinkers and practitioners in this field as
well as commentators on broader matters are united in Reshaping
the Built Environment: Ecology, Ethics & Economics edited by C.
Kilbert (Island Press, 1999). See also David Pearson's Earth
Spirit (Gaia books, 1994) and Living Spaces: Ecological Building
and Design edited by Thomas Schitz-Günther (Køneman, 1999,
English edition). The Findhorn Community has produced some good
technical material on such matters such as John Talbott's Simply
Build Green. So has Ecover, the manufacturer of environmentally
friendlier cleaners and detergents. See The Ecological Factory
by Dick Develter (Ecover, 1992).
On broader matters of appropriate technological design, a number
of names demand mention. They include John Lyle, Victor Papanek,
John and Nancy Todd, David Wann and Sim Van Der Ryn. One of the
best statements of why a greener design ethic is needed and of
its principles is to be found in an essay Sharing Smaller Pies
by Tom Bender, a version of which was included in a very useful
volume Resettling America: Energy, Ecology and Community, edited
by Gary Coates whose own contributions are excellent as well
(Brick House, 1982). The Rocky Mountain Institute (Colorado,
USA) and the Centre for Alternative Technology (Machynlleth,
Wales) are good sources of inspirational ideas in many fields.
With specific respect to land use planning, the seminal work
remains Design With Nature by Ian McHarg (Academic Press, 1969).
| 19. |
Ecoforestry: The Art and Science of Sustainable Forest Use |
| edited by Alan Drengson and Duncan Taylor (New Society Publishers, 1997). |
|
Farming and forestry have wrecked the Earth on a far, far
greater scale than many traditional protest targets such as
hunts, fur farms or new motorways. This book is a case study of
how to put forestry on a more sustainable footing in an approach
that firmly recognises the needs of non-human species. It also
addresses the social and economic dimensions of the needed
revolution in land use. (Drengson's own writings on both
ecophilosophy and technology are well worth seeking out)
See also Forestopia: a Practical Guide to the New Forest Economy
by Michael M'Gonigle and Ben Parfitt (Harbour publishing, 1994).
With regard to the production of food and other crops, there are
several good books on organic farming and community-supported
farms but particularly stimulating are Forest Farming by Robert
Hart (Green books, 1991) and New Roots for Agriculture by Wes
Jackson (Univ. Nebraska Press, 1985) as well as the various
writing of Bill Mollison.
| 20. |
Cascadia Wild |
| edited by Mitch Friedman and Paul Lindholdt (Frontier Publishing, 1993). |
|
Finally, since sustainability is not just about people, here is
a book which points the way to protect remaining wildernesses
and ensure habitats for the Earth's other dependants. Their
biggest problem is simply that we humans leave less and less
space for them. Apart from being an excellent case study (set in
the mountains of the north west United States), it is also an
introduction to some great writers in the field of wildlife
conservation such as Reed Noss and Ed Grumbine.
Other case studies in repairing some of the appalling damage
humankind has inflicted on Mother earth can be found in Helping
Nature Heal: an Introduction to Environmental Restoration edited
by Richard Nilsen (Ten Speed Press, 1991) and In the Service of
the Wild: Restoring and Reinhabiting Damaged Land by Stephanie
Mills (Beacon, 1995). See also Saving Nature's Legacy by Reed
Noss and Allan Cooperrider (Island Press, 1994) and The
Wildlands Project, a special issue of the excellent American
magazine Wild Earth (1992).
|